fbpx
维基百科

深沈之歌比賽

一月 01, 1970

深沈之歌比賽(El Concurso del Cante Jondo)是歷史上一個重要的佛朗明哥比賽，於 1922 年6月 13、14日的基督聖體聖血節，在西班牙安達魯西亞的格拉那達舉行。

法雅的目的 编辑

西班牙古典音樂作曲家法雅(1876–1946), 是這次比賽的主要策劃人。他希望鼓勵推廣已經陷入低潮的佛朗明哥表演。法雅認為佛朗明哥是一種相當有價值的藝術形式，花了許多時間研讀佛朗明哥音樂。身為一個加地斯人，法雅從吉普賽的朋友、歌手、吉他手聽到佛朗明哥。法雅認為爭取菁英份子的支持是很重要的，因為九八世代的西班牙菁英份子主張了被稱為 antiflamenguismo 的反對佛朗明哥主義，九八世代他們認為佛朗明哥阻礙了他們推動西班牙現代化的過程。所以法雅希望不只能影響佛朗明哥界，也能影響音樂界跟文化界人士。


為了能夠找到同好來支持並且推廣深沈之歌比賽，法雅聚集了一票厲害的音樂家跟藝術家。當中有年輕的詩人費德里戈·加西亞·洛爾卡。23歲的詩人洛爾卡成為推廣比賽第二積極的人物。他藉著演講跟撰寫散文來推廣此次比賽。第三個重要策劃者是出身巴斯克地區的畫家 Ignácio Zuloaga. [13] 參與活動的古典音樂家有 Joaquín Turina, Federico Mompou, Conrado del Campo, 跟 Oscar Esplá, 還有鋼琴家兼作曲家 María Rodrigo, 紐約的作曲家兼指揮家 Kurt Schindler 古典吉他手 Andrés Segovia, 波蘭歌手 Aga Lahowska, 流行樂吉他手 Manuel Jofré,知名的安達魯西亞詩人 Juan Ramón Jiménez 也加入了。還有作家 Ramón Pérez de Ayala 跟 Tomás Borrás, 超現實主義畫家 Manuel Ángeles Ortiz。 Centro Artístico of Granada 組織也參與籌備，另外還有教育界的教授例如 Francisco Giner de los Ríos 跟音樂學及作曲教授 Felipe Pedrell (他是法雅的音樂老師).[14] 後來並且加入了法國作家 Maurice Legendre, 音樂評論家包括馬德里報紙"El Sol"的 Adolfo Salazar。[1][2][3][4][5] 法雅也打算邀請法國音樂家拉威爾跟俄國的史特拉汶斯基，但是市政府拒絕提供提供旅費。 [6]


法雅跟佛朗明哥的關係 编辑

在他之前的古典音樂作曲，法雅受到佛朗明哥音樂的影響，例如他的作品 短暫人生(La Vida Breve) (1904–1905, 1913),[7] 西班牙花園之夜(Noches en los Jardines de España) (1909–1916),[8][9]三角帽( El Sombrero de Tres Picos ) (1917, 1919),[10][11] 跟魔幻之愛(El Amor Brujo) (1915, 1925)。[12] 為了推廣此比賽，法雅寫了一篇散文 深歌" (安達魯西亞原始歌唱),[13] 在這篇文章他在技術層面分析了，影響佛朗明哥主要是，從東地中海來的拜占庭教會音樂、[14][15] 從北非跟阿拉伯來的摩爾人音樂、[16][17][18] 還有五百年前跟著吉普賽人吉普賽音樂跟印度的 Tala 音樂。[19][20][21][22]

將近有一個世紀，歐洲的古典音樂作曲家從西班牙音樂獲取養分，而佛朗明哥是其中重要的一部份。[23][24][25] 國際音樂界對佛朗明哥的興趣，跟西班牙文化菁英對佛朗明哥的不尊重，形成對比。[26][27] [28] 法雅希望"能夠恢復這些偉大歌曲的純淨，正確的成為歐洲音樂成就偉大的一部份。" ".[29] 但這個"挽救佛朗明哥"的美夢，也被一些人批評。[30]

公開募款 编辑

 
The Alhambra in Granada, from Mirador de San Nicolás.

比賽的經費來源是由格拉那達市政府所提供，[31][32] 但也不是沒有人反對。 當信徒讚揚佛朗明哥的古老跟純淨，是從人類靈魂的泉源產生，同時也有批評者指出，有時佛朗明哥是在不良場所表演劣質的音樂跟表演。[33] 比賽的支持者們，認為自己是這脆弱的佛朗明哥藝術的拯救者，對於他們對手的指控有點無法招架。[34] 為了擺脫這些不必要的包袱，比賽稱呼這種藝術形式為"深沈之歌"而不是"佛朗明哥"。[35][36] 所以法雅說：「我們是要淨化並且復興這可敬的"深沈之歌"，並不是已經墮落的"佛朗明哥"，不要把這兩者搞混了。」(Queremos purificar y hacer revivir ese admirable cante jondo, que no hay que confundir con el cante flamenco, degeneración y casi caricatura de aquél.)[37][38]

在市政府，是否要財務支持深歌大賽的論戰持續進行著，而募款也繼續著。[39] 關於佛朗明哥本質的爭論，持續到現在還進行著。像是一個大湯鍋裡面煮著一堆帶著刺的原料，包括了社會階級、跟種族、更多時候是表演者的才能、正統性、靈感。 佛朗明哥是一種充分發展的音樂形式，分析的角度可能應該從人類學跟音樂學，這些爭論隨然常被提起，也常常被忽略。[40][41][42] 隨著日期的接近，比賽的場地由阿爾拜辛區的 San Nicolás 廣場，改成阿爾罕布拉宮。[43]

比賽內容 编辑

參與的藝術家 编辑

舉辦深沈之歌比賽的其中一項目的，是希望發覺有才華卻沒有被發現的藝術家。因此，超過 21 歲的專業人士不被允許參加有獎金的比賽。 [44][45][46] 儘管如此，專業的歌唱跟跳舞表演還是被鼓勵的。[47] 雖然花了大量的努力，並沒有找到多少不知名的藝術家。 洛爾卡找到一個失明的老太太，會唱一種被認為已經失傳的liviana曲式。 [48][49]

觀眾跟形式 编辑

活動在兩天的基督聖體聖血節節日的傍晚舉行，有大約四千個支持者跟佛朗明哥迷參加，這個大聚會的氣氛被描述為優雅又愉快的。當表演開始，觀眾的焦點就集中在表演上了。[50][51] 參賽者被邀請表演被稱為深沈之歌(Cante Jondo 或 Cante Grande)的佛朗明哥曲式[52] 包括了 1) Siguiriyas gitana; 2) Serranas, Polos, Cañas, Solea;還有 3) Martinetes-Carceleras, Tonás, Livianas, Saetas Viejas (最後這四種是屬於無伴奏曲式). 另一方面，不夠古老或不夠深沈的曲式，被明確的禁止，包括了: Malagueña, Granaínas, Rondeña, 賽維雅那舞曲, Peteneras.[53]

 
Torre de la Justicia, original entry gate to the Alhambra; and, the walk way to the June evening's Concurso events.

比賽的場地 编辑

比賽在阿爾罕布拉宮西面的[54]的Plaza de Aljibes 舉行，跟 Torre Bermeja 還有西南邊的格拉那達老城區對望; 北邊是吉普賽區Sacromonte的山坡。[55]充滿了柏木的香味，地面上還灑了法國薰衣草。廣場在山脊頂，要穿過正義之塔旁邊的路才能到達。廣場由Ignacio Zuloaga的作品布置，上面還掛著鑲邊的紡織品跟披肩; 在太陽西下時，整個場地就變成了這個阿拉伯宮殿旁邊一塊充滿色彩的區塊。[56][57] 評審團包括了吉他手Andrés Segovia跟佛朗明哥歌手Antonio Chacón。可能有點諷刺的一點是，開場表演是由 Segovia 演奏法雅的古典音樂作品：用吉他對德布西致敬。[58][59][60]

參賽者 编辑

一個退休很久的72歲佛朗明哥歌手Diego Bermúdez Cala(藝名El Tenazas), 意外成為比賽的超級明星。他從家鄉 Puente Genil 花了三天走了大概一百公里到格拉那達去參加比賽。[61] 很明顯的，三十年前被刀尖刺穿肺部，導致他從佛朗明哥圈子提早退休了，這項比賽讓他重享他生命中的重要時刻。他演唱的曲式是屬於上一個時代的，很多人覺得 Bermúdez 的歌唱聽起來，似乎就是得到傳奇歌手Silverio Franconetti的真傳; 雖然一些其他人說他不知道怎麼唱歌，只會調情。[62][63] "El Tenazas 知道古老的曲調，並且用非常佛朗明哥風味的方式去詮釋它們，他用一種幾十年來沒人聽過的純粹佛朗明哥方式歌唱，尤其是在 siguiriyas, 孤調, and cañas (Silverio Franconetti 最喜歡的曲式之一).[64] 在聽到El Tenazas (意思是：鉗子)歌唱時"把他的歌聲拋到天上"，Antonio Chacón驚呼了"老天爺，我聽到了甚麼！"[65] 法雅後來 1939 年因為佛朗哥將軍打贏了西班牙內戰，而流亡到阿根廷的時候，還帶了一份 El Tenazas 的錄音(Cantos de Diego Bermúdez)去。[66] El Tenazas 很享受他突然回復的名氣，藉此他接下來就在西班牙各地巡迴演出佛朗明哥歌唱。但很可惜的，一年後他就去世了。[67] 另外一個首獎得主是年僅十二歲的 Manolo Ortega，後來被稱為El Caracol, 出身於一個知名的鬥牛士跟吉普賽家庭，後來獲得的極大的名聲，也引起了很大的爭議。[68][69] 另一個贏家是出身格拉那達的流行歌手Francisco Gálvez Gómez (Yerbagüena), 他以當地一個教堂火災為題材，即興寫了佛朗明哥歌詞來表演，讓觀眾留下深刻印象。[70] 總共有十個參賽者贏得了數目不等的獎金。[71][72]

專家表演 编辑

專業佛朗明哥藝術家在比賽中雖然不能參加有獎金的比賽，依然還是被尊崇的，並且列為特別來賓，包括了女歌手Pastora Pavón (La Niña de los Peines),[73]、男歌手Manuel Torre, 女舞者Juana la Macarrona. 還有男歌手Antonio Chacón, 被選為評審。這四位當時已經很有名了。在一幅繪畫中畫出了藝術家們在比賽舉辦人面前表演，La Niña de los Peines, 前面提過的退休的El Tenazas) 還有創新的佛朗明哥吉他手 Ramón Montoya Salazar。[74] 另外也有一位在巴黎開佛朗明哥咖啡館的 Amalio Cuenca 也被選為評審。[75] 專業藝術家從從西班牙各地甚至外國來參加比賽。 在比賽中，偉大的 Manuel Torre 配著當地 Sacromonte 區的吉普賽女人的擊掌，吟唱了歡愉調(alegrías)。 María Amaya La Gazpacha 唱了喧戲調(bulerías)跟tarantas，由Pepe Cuéllar 彈吉他幫她伴奏。 [76] Ramon Montoya, Manolo de Huelva, 跟 José Cuéllar 這三位被比賽聘請的吉他手，組成了吉他三重奏，為年長的舞蹈大師Juana la Macarrona （页面存档备份，存于互联网档案馆）表演的 alegrías 舞蹈伴奏。[77] [78] La Macarrona 她在比賽途中有時候會大聲喊叫:"¡Lapoteosis! ¡Es lapoteosis!"意思類似於"打雷了！"。[79] 在比賽中一場表演，Antonio Chacón 唱歌 Ramón Montoya 伴奏，一個衣衫藍縷的吉普賽女人安靜的哭泣，站起來抬起頭，配著音樂跳了一首極為動人且優雅的孤調。她其實是幾十年前一個有名的佛朗明哥舞者 La Golondrina [80]


比賽的新聞 编辑

跟摩洛哥戰爭令人沮喪的消息相比，西班牙媒體普遍讚揚這次比賽。,[81] 一家馬德里雜誌新世界描述這次比賽是"令人難忘的"關於觀眾，它這樣描寫:

"月亮沒有參加，但是比賽場地擠滿了小精靈、仙子、甚至魔鬼。一個超級票房冠軍，座無虛席，並且是一群有紀律、有文化的觀眾。觀眾主要是女性，穿著 1830 年的服裝，其他人穿著老式的長褲，她們所有人帶著格拉那達人特有的穩重。群眾扇著扇子交談著，直到一首歌曲用感動麻痺了群眾們…"[82]

格拉那達的雜誌阿爾罕布拉宮盛讚比賽為"精彩的晚會"。在馬德里，媒體評論宣稱"比賽非常的成功"。[83] 雖然如此，法雅還是失望的。[84]

後續發展 编辑

 
Manuel de Falla (1876-1946)

比賽的表演廣受好評，但比賽的成果則有爭議。[85] 比賽本身很令人享受，也成功的集結了表演者跟樂迷，並且提升了佛朗明哥在西班牙的文化界領袖心中的地位。[86] 各種佛朗明哥曲式的錄音被灌錄了，有些曲式之前很少人知道，有些曲式則是被重新發現。[87] 比如；La Caña:

"它是一種古老的曲式，用宗教旋律跟吟唱橋段，讓它成為"佛朗明哥彌撒"。在二十世紀幾乎完全消失了，卻在 1922 年格拉那達的比賽中，由優勝者 El Tenazas 的錄音被重新發現了。[88]

另一方面，提升佛朗明哥表演純淨本質的目的，卻沒有達成。[89] 佛朗明哥劇場時代即將來臨，這是一種在現代已經因為它擺架子的形式、跟其他音樂的混合，被鄙視的形式。 [90][91]

在同一年，類似的佛朗明哥比賽也在賽維亞跟加地斯舉行了。[92][93]幾十年後的 1956 年哥多華市舉行了全國深沈之歌比賽[94] 在 1962 年Jerez de la Frontera舉辦了國際佛朗明哥藝術比賽，這樣的活動已經成為佛朗明哥文化的一種常態。[95]


外部連結 编辑

參考來源 编辑

  1. ^ Eduardo Molina Fajardo, Manuel de Falla y El "Cante Jondo" (Universidad de Granada 1962; 2d editión 1998, with new preface at ix-cviii by Andrés Soria), at lxi, lxx, and 54-57.
  2. ^ Ángel Álvarez Caballero, El cante flamenco (Madrid: Alianza Editorial 1994) at 212.
  3. ^ Félix Grande, Memoria del Flamenco (Madrid: Espasa-Calpe 1979) at II: 481.
  4. ^ Manuel Orozco Diaz, Falla (Barcelona: Salvat 1985) at 123-124.
  5. ^ Barbara Thiel-Cramér, Flamenco. The Art of Flamenco, Its History and Development until our Days (Lindingö, Sweden: Remark 1990 [Swedish], 1991 [Spanish, German, English]) at 51–52.
  6. ^ 法雅也打算邀請音樂家 拉威爾 跟俄國的史特拉汶斯基，但是市政府拒絕提供提供旅費。. [2012-01-21]. 
  7. ^ Eduardo Molina Fajardo, Manuel de Falla y El "Cante Jondo" (Universidad de Granada 1962; 2d edition 1998) at 13-23, 17. Thesoleares in Falla's La Vida Breve is mentioned, during a review of Falla's classical compositions relating to flamenco music. Molina Fajardo at 15 gives his opinion as to how in general Falla incorporated flamenco elements in his art: by drinking in and assimilating their spirit, and then expressing their musical essence. Later he comments on the pervasive use of flamenco in Noches en los Jardines de España, El Amor Brujo, and El Sombrero de Tres Picos.
  8. ^ In Falla's Noches, Gypsies dance and sing during the feast of Corpus Christi, the days later selected by Falla for the Concurso.
  9. ^ Betty Keim, "Manuel de Falla: the Guitar and his Music" in The Guitar Review (Winter 1976) 41:22-23, wherein Keim mentions the melodies inspired bycante jondo, and the "rasgueado" and "punteado" in his Noches en los Jardines de España, which ends with a sevillana.
  10. ^ Cf., Lynn Garafola, Diaghilev's Ballets Russes (Oxford Univ. 1989) at 88-90, discussing Falla and flamenco dance projects circa 1916-1917. Falla's El Sombrero de Tres Picos [The Three-cornered Hat;Fr: Le Tricorne], choreographed by Leonide Massine, designs by Pablo Picasso, was produced by the Ballets Russes in 1919. Garafola (1989) at 88, 243, 253.
  11. ^ The flamenco and Spanish origin of both the music and the dance in Le Tricorne is described by Léonide Massine in his My Life in Ballet (London: Macmillan 1968) at 114-118, 122.
  12. ^ Betty Keim, "Manuel de Falla: the Guitar and his Music" in The Guitar Review (Winter 1976) 41:22-23. Keim mentions several other examples of Falla's use of flamenco: the modified farruca for the "Miller's Dance" [Danza del Molinero] in his El Sombrero de Tres Picos (at the end the miller becomes "possessed by the duende"); and, the "falsetas" and "paseos" in his Siete Canciones Populares Españoles (1914), where she again remarks that his piano pieces seem "written as if they were guitar music," especially regarding the "Polo", as well as the "Seguidilla Murciana". Keim also references the memorable "Ritual Fire Dance" in his El Amor Brujo, which is performed at night in a Gypsi camp.
  13. ^ Manuel de Falla, El "cante jondo" (canto primitivo andaluz), a folleto (Granada: Urania 1922); included in Molina Fajardo,Manuel de Falla y El "Cante Jondo" (1962, 1998) at 209-226 [Byzantine liturgical at 209-210; Arabic, Moorish at 210-211, 225-226; Gypsies of India at 211-216]; and collected in Falla's Escritos sobre música y músicos (Madrid: Espasa-Calpe 1950, 1972), Apéndice at 137-155. Falla here refers to his former music professor Felipe Pedrell (1841-1922).
  14. ^ Cf., Peter Crossley-Holland, "Ancient Greece" at 92-103; and, Alec Robertson, "Byzantine and Russian Rites" at 201-208; in: Robertson and Stevens (eds.), The Pelican History of Music (Penguin Books 1960).
  15. ^ Cf., Adolfo Salazar, La Música de España (Madrid: Espasa-Calpe 1953), vol. I at Chap. III/1: 137-149. Also, the religious music of the Jews, who had arrived in Hispania by 300 C.E. Salazar, La Música de España (1953), v. I at I/5: 42-46.
  16. ^ Cf., Julián Ribera y Taregó, La Música de las Cantigas (Madrid 1922), translated and abridged by Eleanor Hague and Marion Leffingwell as Music in Ancient Arabia and Spain (Stanford Univ. 1929).
  17. ^ Arcadio de Larrea Palacin, La Música Hispano-Árabe (Madrid: Ateneo 1957), a folleto.
  18. ^ Cf., Owen Wright, "Music in Muslim Spain" 555-579, in Salma Khadra Jayyusi, editor,The Legacy of Muslim Spain (Leiden: E. J. Brill 1992).
  19. ^ Aziz Balouchi, Cante Jondo. Su origen y evolución (Madrid: Editiones Ensayos 1955) at 30-38. The author, a sufi, discusses the spirit of Indo-Pakistani music, then describes six principal modes. A "tree" is shown (at 37) whose fruit is cante jondo, i.e., "serranas,soleares, polos, seguirillas, cañas". Earlier the author speculates that Ziryab the famous Persian musician, who arrived in Moorish Spain during the 9th century, was a master of "la música persa-baluchi," had studied "el cantar Sindhi" in India, and brought with him to Spain "la música indostánica". Balouchi (1955) at 24-28, 26.
  20. ^ Bernard Leblon, Gypsies and Flamenco (Univ.of Hertfordshire 1995). Leblon, who favored the view of a strong Gitano influence on the art, addresses the theories proposed by Falla (at 85-91). Leblon discounts Falla regarding the Byzantines, then endorses influence by the Moors. Regarding India and Gitano contributions to flamenco, Leblon writes that here Falla makes five points: 1) "use of intervals less than a demi-tone" (smallest interval common to western music) to modulate keys; 2) "a melodic ambitus which rarely exceeds the limits of a sixth" (ninehalf-notes); 3) "repeated, almost obsessive use of a single note" often with appoggiatura; 4) melody rich in ornamentation, suiting the emotion of the lyrics; 5) "shouts [jaleos] used by our people to excite the dancers and guitarists" following ancient custom. Leblon (1995) at 88.
  21. ^ Angus Fraser, The Gypsies (Oxford: Blackwell 1992, 2d ed. 1995) at 10-32 (origin), at 205-208 (flamenco).
  22. ^ The Gypsi road from India to Spain, with music along the way, is displayed in the 1993 French film Latcho Drom.
  23. ^ Manuel de Falla, El "cante jondo" (canto primitivo andaluz), a folleto (Granada: Urania 1922); included in Molina Fajardo,Manuel de Falla y El "Cante Jondo" (1962, 1998) at 209-226, 217-225; collected in Falla's Escritos sobre música y músicos (Madrid: Espasa-Calpe 1950, 1972), Apéndice 137-155. Falla noted that the foreign borrowing of Spanish music went beyond rhythm (usual with dances of other European countries, e.g., the jig, the saraband, the gavote, the minuet); it went further, to the basic modes of expression found in Spanish music. Falla (1922), reprinted in Molina Fajardo (1998) at 218.
  24. ^ Gilbert Chase, The Music of Spain (New York: W.W.Norton 1941; rev.ed., New York: Dover 1959) at 289-304, "The Spell of Spanish Music". Gilbert discusses Falla at 182-197.
  25. ^ The list would include these composers and works: Mikhail Glinka (Jota Aragonesa, 1845), Georges Bizet (Carmen, 1875), Nikolai Rimsky-Korsakov (Capriccio Espagnol, 1887),Claude Debussy (Ibéria, 1905-1908), Maurice Ravel (Rapsodie espagnole, 1907, and Boléro, 1928).
  26. ^ "Pues bien, señores: ese tesoro de belleza, no sólo amenaza ruina, sino que está apunto de desaparecer para siempre." "El canto grave, hierático de ayer, ha degenerado en el ridículo flamenquismo de hoy." Manuel de Falla, "La proposición del cante jondo" en El Defensor de Granada (March 21, 1922), reprinted in Molina Fajardo, Manuel de Falla y El "Cante Jondo" (1962, 1998) at 169-175, 173. "Well, gentlemen, this beautiful treasure not only is about to collapse, but may disappear forever." "The song of gravitas, majestic yesterday, has sunk now to this absurd flamenquismo."
  27. ^ Carol A. Hess, Manuel de Falla and modernism in Spain, 1898-1936 (University of Chicago 2001) at 175 [footnote omitted].
  28. ^ An entry ticket to the event reads: "Concurso y Fiesta del Cante Jondo, Corpus 1922. Entrada de Silla Preferente, para los días 13 y 14 de Junio. Entrada por la Puerta de Justicia. Preséntese a toda reclamación." Molina Fajardo (1998), insert at 129.
  29. ^ Would "renacieron en toda su pureza esos cantos de maravilla, que constituyen uno de los más legítimos orgullos de música natural europea". Manuel de Falla, "La proposición del cante jondo" (Granada 1922), reprinted in Molina Fajardo (1962, 1998) at 169-175, 174-175.
  30. ^ Timothy Mitchell, in his Flamenco Deep Song (New Haven: Yale University 1994), disputes the very notion of a traditional "purity" as advanced by Concurso proponents. For example, regarding the seguiriya gitana Mitchell describes it as a result of "lower-class gitanos, payo [non-Gitano] ruffians, blind beggars, female mourners for hire, and proletarian youth" which later was evolved in the 19th century by "professional cantaores" entertaining within the cultural maze of Spanish society, at venues including "private juergas [parties] and public saloons." Mitchell (1994) at 168.
  31. ^ Written application for support was made on December 31, 1921, giving artistic and cultural reasons as redacted by Miguel Cerón, and signed by several dozen adherents. Molina Fajardo,Manuel de Falla y El "Cante Jondo" (1962, 1998) at 51-58, 51-53; also, Solicitud Al Ayuntamiento de Granada reprinted in Molina Fajardo (1998) as Apéndice II at 163-167.
  32. ^ Álvarez Caballero, El cante flamenco (1994) at 217, gives the amount of city funding at 30,000pesetas.
  33. ^ Eduardo Molina Fajardo, Manuel de Falla y El "Cante Jondo" (Universidad de Granada 1962; 2d ed. 1998) at 69-87.
  34. ^ Timothy Mitchell, Flamenco Deep Song(New Haven: Yale University 1994) at 168-169.
  35. ^ Robin Totton, Song of the Outcasts (Portland, Oregon: Amadeus Press 2003) at 84.
  36. ^ Leblon, Gypsies and Flamenco (University of Hertfordshire 1995) at 87-88.
  37. ^ "We want to purify and renew the admirablecante jondo, which is not to be confused with flamenco, a degeneration of it, almost a caricature." 法雅寫給倫敦評論家 John Trend 的信, Molina Fajardo 引用在 Manuel de Falla y El "Cante Jondo" 書中，(1962; 1998) 76-77 頁。
  38. ^ Cf., Ángel Álvarez Caballero, El cante flamenco (Madrid: Alianza Editorial 1994) at 213-214.
  39. ^ Eduardo Molina Fajardo in his Manuel de Falla y El "Cante Jondo" (Universidad de Granada 1962; 2d ed. 1998) at 92-93, 141.
  40. ^ Among factors in the cauldron are the dynamic opposition of flamenco tradition versus innovation, the latter frequently including interpenetration with other musical styles. E.g., Manuel Ríos Ruiz, Ayer y Hoy del cante flameno (Madrid: Ediciones ISTMO 1997) at 85-95. Recent decades have seen Nuevo Flamenco emerge with rock and jazz connections.
  41. ^ Flamenco motivation is notoriously difficult to pin down. "Existe en plenitud anárquica, independiente de todo acicate organizado." "Fully anarchic, blind to organized incentives." Anselmo Gazález Climent, Flamencología. Toros, Cante y Baile (Madrid: Editorial Escelicer 1955, 1964) at 272. See Gazález Climent's comments on the nuance involved in the rôle of La guasa (the tricky, humorous rustic), at 329-341.
  42. ^ On occasion political passions may be stirred, in a sociological view of the art: as embodying the anguished expression of the poor, the oppressed classes. Yet to the contrary, others see flamenco performers of the past, who were often short of resources, as influenced by their wealthy patrons who had a taste for the exotic. An ethnic dimension also arises: as to how much the art owes to its strong Gitano elements, or to the Andalusian. Altogether contrary is the opinion that in flamenco what one hears is the cry of the soul, transcending class, patrons, ethnicity, etc. Wide-ranging views are held by flamencologos on the art and on what motivates a performer. E.g., Anselmo Gazález Climent, Flamencología. Toros, Cante y Baile (Madrid: Editorial Escelicer 1955, 1964); William Washabaugh, Flamenco. Passion, politics and popular culture (Oxford: Berg 1996) at 31-38.
  43. ^ Molina Fajardo in Manuel de Falla y El "Cante Jondo" (1962; 2d ed. 1998) at 129, 131.
  44. ^ Andrés Soria, "Prefacio" at lxix, in Eduardo Molina Fajardo, Manuel de Falla y El "Cante Jondo" (Universidad de Granada 1962; 2d edition 1998, with new preface at ix-cviii by Soria).
  45. ^ The performance of flamenco is very difficult and demanding; only someone who devotes a great deal of their life's nurture to the art will be able to express its subtleties and nuance, its drama and simplicity; often but not always such refinement will acquire wide attention. Cf., Paco Sevilla, "Introductory History of Flamenco, Part II" in Jaleo VIII/2, originally published in Guitar and Lute (March 1983), at ¶14.
  46. ^ The elimination of all professionals from the contest was considered a mistake by many flamencos, for there were those who had not fallen to the era's commercial tendencies. An example would be the professionals hired by the Concurso, the cantaora Pastora Pavón (La Niña de los Peines), the cantaor Manuel Torre, and the bailaora Juana la Macarrona. These had, unlike many paid performers of that decadent era, maintained a purity in their approach to flamenco. Cf., D.E.Pohren, Lives and Legends of Flamenco (Madrid 1964, revised 1988) at 73.
  47. ^ Paul Hecht in his The Wind Cried (New York: The Dial Press 1968) at 105-107, describes a "dream vision of a flamenco contest" in which the performers and local aficionados are given preference. Lasting at minimum several weeks, it would begin with a banquet and include hotel accommodations. Before each session time would be allowed for thawing out the voice and interacting with the listeners. At extra-official Juergas flamenco's "pure spontaneous essence" would be given rein.
  48. ^ Timothy Mitchell, Flameno Deep Song (Yale Univ. 1994) at 170.
  49. ^ The liviana (derived from "liviano" meaning "light, frivolous" and also "the donkey who leads the pack") is a type of siguiriya sung without accompaniment. Andrés Batista, Maestros y Estilos. Manual flamenco (Madrid 1985) at 18-19, 74-75.
  50. ^ Marice Legendre, "El Corpus de Granada in 1922: El Cante Jondo" in the periodical Le Correspondant of Paris, July 1922; cited by Molina Fajardo (1998) at 131-132.
  51. ^ A storm threatened the first night, but the air remained light. The second night rain began to fall, yet the audience remained. Molina Fajardo, Manuel de Falla y El "Cante Jondo" (1998) at 132, 140.
  52. ^ Believed for the most part to be of Gitano (Gypsi) origin. I.e., by D. E. Pohren, Lives and Legends of Flamenco. A Biographical History (Madrid: Society of Spanish Studies [1964] 1988) at 17-20.
  53. ^ The brief Concurso prize and contest rules are reprinted in Manuel de Falla, Escritos sobre música y músicos (Madrid: Espasa-Calpe 1950, 1972), at 156-162 in the Apéndice, following his essay "El Cante Jondo (Canto Primitivo Andaluz)" at 137-155; translated as On Music and Musicians (London: Marion Boyars 1979), at end of Appendix (99-117).
  54. ^ The Alhambra had been the site of the opening for Falla's opera El Sombrero de Tres Picos [French: Le Tricorne] three years ealier in 1919. Léonide Massine, My Life in Ballet (London: Macmillan 1968) at 142.
  55. ^ Ricardo Villa-Real, The Alhambra and the Generalife (Granada: Ed. Miguel Sanchez 1988) at 6-7.
  56. ^ Molina Fajardo, Manuel de Falla y El "Cante Jondo" (Univ.de Granada 1962; 2d ed. 1998) at 118-119.
  57. ^ Irving Brown, Deep Song (New York: Harper & Brothers 1929) at 149-150.
  58. ^ Molina Fajardo, Manuel de Falla y El "Cante Jondo" (Univ.de Granada 1962; 2d ed. 1998) at 116. It was Claude Debussy who had first shown Falla how to find the flamenco's true spirit in the guitar music of the cante jondo. Ibid. at 17-18.
  59. ^ Nota Bene: Segovia at this time played flamenco as well as classical guitar (to the latter he would soon devote his entire effort). Pohlen, Lives and Legends of Flamenco (Madrid 1964, revised 1988) at 73.
  60. ^ Cf., Betty Keim, in her "Manuel de Falla: the Guitar and his Music" published in The Guitar Review (Winter 1976) 41:22-23, notes that Falla called meeting Claude Debussy the "turning point" of his career. Falla wrote the Homenaje following Debussy's death in 1918, then gave it to the guitarist Miguel Llobet. The score is widely acclaimed for its mastery of the instrument and, while not flamenco, its beauty resonates with the music of Andalusia.
  61. ^ Puente Genil is about 50 km. south of Córdoba. Diego Bermúdez was born 1850 at Morón de la Frontera about 70 km. southwest of Puente Genil. Pohlen, Lives and Legends of Flamenco (1988) at 71.
  62. ^ Ángel Álvarez Caballero, El cante flamenco (Madrid: Alianza Editorial 1994) at 218-219. Burmúdez "había dejado de cantar treinta años antes al perder facultades a causa de una puñalada recibada en el pulmón durante una reyerta." His punctured lung, Ibid. at 218. Fixed to a wall of a cafe in Puente Genil could later be seen a certificate signed by Antonio Chacón that the Concurso had awarded to Tío Bermúdez (at 219). The walk from Puente Genil to Granada for the Concurso was said to have taken him only three days, but long and exhausting ones; but some doubt he walked the distance (at 218).
  63. ^ Cf., Molina Fajardo, Manuel de Falla y El "Cante Jondo" (Univ. de Granada 1962; 2d ed. 1998) at 135-136, 140.
  64. ^ D.E.Pohlen, Lives and Legends of Flamenco (1988) at 71-72.
  65. ^ "Lord help me, what I hear!" Jose Luis Cano, García Lorca (Barcelona: Salvat Editores 1985) at 55.
  66. ^ Félix Grande, Memoria del Flamenco (Madrid: Espasa-Calpe 1979) at II: 507.
  67. ^ Before he died el Tío Tenazas traveled Spain performing his prize-winning singing style but, as his innovations had already been copied by younger singers, the tour was evidently not well received. Timothy Mitchell, Flamenco Deep Song (Yale Univ. 1994) at 171.
  68. ^ Eduardo Molina Fajardo, Manuel de Falla y El "Cante Jondo" (Universidade Granada 1962; 2d ed. 1998) at 133, 141.
  69. ^ D. E. Pohren, Lives and Legends of Flamenco (Madrid: Society of Spanish Studies 1985) at 146-150, 148.
  70. ^ Ángel Álvarez Caballero, El cante flamenco (Madrid: Alianza Editorial 1994) at 219-220. Yerbagüena figured in the novel La oración de la tarde by González Anaya. The poet Alvarez de Cienfuegos recited at his burial.
  71. ^ Eduardo Molina Fajardo lists the prize winners in his Manuel de Falla y El "Cante Jondo" (Univ. de Granada 1962; 2d ed. 1998) at 141-142. The top two prize winners received 1000 pesetas each, with total prize money for the contestants being almost 5000. Yet he cites a newspaper of Seville to the effect that the biggest winners was the Concurso organizer, Centro Artístico, who after event expenses, with the gate (6,000 pesetas) added to public funding, managed to come out ahead. Molina Fajardo (1998) at 142.
  72. ^ Álvarez Caballero, El cante flamenco (1994) at 217 puts the gate at 30,000, and at 213 puts the public funding at 12,000. Expense amounts do not seem to be stated.
  73. ^ Pastora Pavón was also an honorary judge but without a vote. Paco Sevilla, Queen of the Gypsies (1999) at 153.
  74. ^ Ángel Álvarez Caballero, El cante flamenco (Madrid: Alianza Editorial 1994) at 216, 210 (drawing).
  75. ^ D. E. Pohlen, Lives and Legends of Flamenco (Madrid 1964, revised 1988) at 273 (Cuenca). Also, Pohlen's literary portraits at 112-114 (Pavón), at 91-97 (Torre), at 212-215 (Macarrona), and at 76-80 (Chacón).
  76. ^ Eduardo Molina Fajardo, Manuel de Falla y El "Cante Jondo" (Universidad de Granada 1962; 2d ed. 1998) at 136-139. María Amaya was also a prize winner. Ibid. at 142.
  77. ^ Pohlen, Lives and Legends of Flamenco (1964, 1988) at 73.
  78. ^ Antonia Mercé la Argentina, after watching Juana la Macarrona dance during the Concurso, later knelt down at her feet, took off her shoes, and carried them away. Flamenco World article on Juana la Macarrona （页面存档备份，存于互联网档案馆）
  79. ^ Molina Fajardo, Manuel de Falla y el "Cante Jondo" (1962, 2d ed. 1988) at 136, 139.
  80. ^ Timothy Mitchell, Flamenco Deep Song (Yale Univ. 1994) at 170.
  81. ^ Some Concurso critics, however, seemed to revisit the earlier contra position (see above the section "Public funding").
  82. ^ Frederico García Sanchíz, "Granada. El Concurso de Cante Jondo" （页面存档备份，存于互联网档案馆） 馬德里的雜誌 Nuevo Mundo(新世界)1922年6月23,flamenco-world.com 網站的英文翻譯。
  83. ^ "A few nights of brilliance." "Great has been the success of the Concurso." Eduardo Molina Fajardo, Manuel de Falla y El "Cante Jondo" (Universidad de Granada 1962; 2d ed. 1998) at 144.
  84. ^ Eduardo Molina Fajardo, Manuel de Falla y El "Cante Jondo" (1962, 1998) at 151-157.
  85. ^ The sevillano Rodriguez de Leon writing in El Sol lamented the Concurso as cause of the "funerales por el alma del cante, muerto recientemente en Granada, a manos de los intelectuales... ." Cited by Ángel Álvarez Caballero, El cante flamenco (Madrid: Alianza Editorial 1994) at 217. I.e., the lamented Concurso has caused "funerals for the soul of the cante, recently dead in Granada, at the hands of the intellectuals."
  86. ^ Félix Grande, Memoria del Flamenco (Madrid: Espasa-Calpe 1979) at II: 514.
  87. ^ Paco Sevilla, "Introductory History of Flamenco, Part II" inJaleo VIII/2, originally published in Guitar and Lute (March 1983), at ¶ 14.
  88. ^ Paco Sevilla, Queen of the Gypsies. The Life and Legend of Carmen Amaya (San Diego 1999) at 197.
  89. ^ The initial elation and sense of accomplishment by those attending the event was manifest. Yet following the Concurso, in addition to the usual sniping at success in the press, there was a distressing sense of loss felt by the Concurso organizers. Hence they abandoned pursuit of their original long-term goals, plans scheduled to be implimented following the Concurso event.

    "It was disillusioning to the organizers that the true purpose of the concurso failed, at least during their lifetimes. ... The Granada contest was designed as only the first step. As a followup, they intended to open flamenco schools in Andalusian cities and to hire flamenco's old-timers to instruct the youngsters in the pure cante. The Centro Artístico of Granada, which was to have played an important part in this plan, at the last minute pulled out, and the whole idea collapsed." D.E.Pohren, Lives and Legends of Flamenco (Madrid: Society of Spanish Studies 1964, revised 1988) at 73-74.

    Yet the continuance of "Concurso" events in different cities and the current spread offlamenco schools perhaps means "that Manuel de Falla's dream may yet come true". D.E.Pohren (1964, 1988) at 74. Or perhaps now his dream has been realized, in part.
  90. ^ Félix Grande,Memoria del Flamenco (Madrid: Espasa-Calpe 1979) at II: 517-539.
  91. ^ Ángel Álvarez Caballero, El cante flamenco (Madrid: Alianza Editorial 1994) at 229-244.
  92. ^ Félix Grande,Memoria del Flamenco (Madrid: Espasa-Calpe 1979) at II: 513.
  93. ^ Cf., Paco Sevilla, Queen of the Gypsies (1999) at 40-41.
  94. ^ Ángel Álvarez Caballero, El cante flamenco (Madrid: Alianza Editorial 1994, 1998) at 262.
  95. ^ Félix Grande,Memoria del Flamenco (Madrid: Espasa-Calpe 1979) at II: 513-514.

一月 01, 1970
深沈之歌比賽, concurso, cante, jondo, 是歷史上一個重要的佛朗明哥比賽, 1922, 年6月, 14日的基督聖體聖血節, 在西班牙安達魯西亞的格拉那達舉行, 目录, 法雅的目的, 法雅跟佛朗明哥的關係, 公開募款, 比賽內容, 參與的藝術家, 觀眾跟形式, 比賽的場地, 參賽者, 專家表演, 比賽的新聞, 後續發展, 外部連結, 參考來源法雅的目的, 编辑西班牙古典音樂作曲家法雅, 1876, 1946, 是這次比賽的主要策劃人, 他希望鼓勵推廣已經陷入低潮的佛朗明哥表演, 法雅認為佛朗明哥. 深沈之歌比賽 El Concurso del Cante Jondo 是歷史上一個重要的佛朗明哥比賽 於 1922 年6月 13 14日的基督聖體聖血節 在西班牙安達魯西亞的格拉那達舉行 目录 1 法雅的目的 2 法雅跟佛朗明哥的關係 3 公開募款 4 比賽內容 4 1 參與的藝術家 4 2 觀眾跟形式 4 3 比賽的場地 4 4 參賽者 4 5 專家表演 4 6 比賽的新聞 5 後續發展 6 外部連結 7 參考來源法雅的目的 编辑西班牙古典音樂作曲家法雅 1876 1946 是這次比賽的主要策劃人 他希望鼓勵推廣已經陷入低潮的佛朗明哥表演 法雅認為佛朗明哥是一種相當有價值的藝術形式 花了許多時間研讀佛朗明哥音樂 身為一個加地斯人 法雅從吉普賽的朋友 歌手 吉他手聽到佛朗明哥 法雅認為爭取菁英份子的支持是很重要的 因為九八世代的西班牙菁英份子主張了被稱為 antiflamenguismo 的反對佛朗明哥主義 九八世代他們認為佛朗明哥阻礙了他們推動西班牙現代化的過程 所以法雅希望不只能影響佛朗明哥界 也能影響音樂界跟文化界人士 為了能夠找到同好來支持並且推廣深沈之歌比賽 法雅聚集了一票厲害的音樂家跟藝術家 當中有年輕的詩人費德里戈 加西亞 洛爾卡 23歲的詩人洛爾卡成為推廣比賽第二積極的人物 他藉著演講跟撰寫散文來推廣此次比賽 第三個重要策劃者是出身巴斯克地區的畫家 Ignacio Zuloaga 13 參與活動的古典音樂家有 Joaquin Turina Federico Mompou Conrado del Campo 跟 Oscar Espla 還有鋼琴家兼作曲家 Maria Rodrigo 紐約的作曲家兼指揮家 Kurt Schindler 古典吉他手 Andres Segovia 波蘭歌手 Aga Lahowska 流行樂吉他手 Manuel Jofre 知名的安達魯西亞詩人 Juan Ramon Jimenez 也加入了 還有作家 Ramon Perez de Ayala 跟 Tomas Borras 超現實主義畫家 Manuel Angeles Ortiz Centro Artistico of Granada 組織也參與籌備 另外還有教育界的教授例如 Francisco Giner de los Rios 跟音樂學及作曲教授 Felipe Pedrell 他是法雅的音樂老師 14 後來並且加入了法國作家 Maurice Legendre 音樂評論家包括馬德里報紙 El Sol 的 Adolfo Salazar 1 2 3 4 5 法雅也打算邀請法國音樂家拉威爾跟俄國的史特拉汶斯基 但是市政府拒絕提供提供旅費 6 法雅跟佛朗明哥的關係 编辑在他之前的古典音樂作曲 法雅受到佛朗明哥音樂的影響 例如他的作品 短暫人生 La Vida Breve 1904 1905 1913 7 西班牙花園之夜 Noches en los Jardines de Espana 1909 1916 8 9 三角帽 El Sombrero de Tres Picos 1917 1919 10 11 跟魔幻之愛 El Amor Brujo 1915 1925 12 為了推廣此比賽 法雅寫了一篇散文 深歌 安達魯西亞原始歌唱 13 在這篇文章他在技術層面分析了 影響佛朗明哥主要是 從東地中海來的拜占庭教會音樂 14 15 從北非跟阿拉伯來的摩爾人音樂 16 17 18 還有五百年前跟著吉普賽人吉普賽音樂跟印度的 Tala 音樂 19 20 21 22 將近有一個世紀 歐洲的古典音樂作曲家從西班牙音樂獲取養分 而佛朗明哥是其中重要的一部份 23 24 25 國際音樂界對佛朗明哥的興趣 跟西班牙文化菁英對佛朗明哥的不尊重 形成對比 26 27 28 法雅希望 能夠恢復這些偉大歌曲的純淨 正確的成為歐洲音樂成就偉大的一部份 29 但這個 挽救佛朗明哥 的美夢 也被一些人批評 30 公開募款 编辑 nbsp The Alhambra in Granada from Mirador de San Nicolas 比賽的經費來源是由格拉那達市政府所提供 31 32 但也不是沒有人反對 當信徒讚揚佛朗明哥的古老跟純淨 是從人類靈魂的泉源產生 同時也有批評者指出 有時佛朗明哥是在不良場所表演劣質的音樂跟表演 33 比賽的支持者們 認為自己是這脆弱的佛朗明哥藝術的拯救者 對於他們對手的指控有點無法招架 34 為了擺脫這些不必要的包袱 比賽稱呼這種藝術形式為 深沈之歌 而不是 佛朗明哥 35 36 所以法雅說 我們是要淨化並且復興這可敬的 深沈之歌 並不是已經墮落的 佛朗明哥 不要把這兩者搞混了 Queremos purificar y hacer revivir ese admirable cante jondo que no hay que confundir con el cante flamenco degeneracion y casi caricatura de aquel 37 38 在市政府 是否要財務支持深歌大賽的論戰持續進行著 而募款也繼續著 39 關於佛朗明哥本質的爭論 持續到現在還進行著 像是一個大湯鍋裡面煮著一堆帶著刺的原料 包括了社會階級 跟種族 更多時候是表演者的才能 正統性 靈感 佛朗明哥是一種充分發展的音樂形式 分析的角度可能應該從人類學跟音樂學 這些爭論隨然常被提起 也常常被忽略 40 41 42 隨著日期的接近 比賽的場地由阿爾拜辛區的 San Nicolas 廣場 改成阿爾罕布拉宮 43 比賽內容 编辑參與的藝術家 编辑 舉辦深沈之歌比賽的其中一項目的 是希望發覺有才華卻沒有被發現的藝術家 因此 超過 21 歲的專業人士不被允許參加有獎金的比賽 44 45 46 儘管如此 專業的歌唱跟跳舞表演還是被鼓勵的 47 雖然花了大量的努力 並沒有找到多少不知名的藝術家 洛爾卡找到一個失明的老太太 會唱一種被認為已經失傳的liviana曲式 48 49 觀眾跟形式 编辑 活動在兩天的基督聖體聖血節節日的傍晚舉行 有大約四千個支持者跟佛朗明哥迷參加 這個大聚會的氣氛被描述為優雅又愉快的 當表演開始 觀眾的焦點就集中在表演上了 50 51 參賽者被邀請表演被稱為深沈之歌 Cante Jondo 或 Cante Grande 的佛朗明哥曲式 52 包括了 1 Siguiriyas gitana 2 Serranas Polos Canas Solea 還有 3 Martinetes Carceleras Tonas Livianas Saetas Viejas 最後這四種是屬於無伴奏曲式 另一方面 不夠古老或不夠深沈的曲式 被明確的禁止 包括了 Malaguena Granainas Rondena 賽維雅那舞曲 Peteneras 53 nbsp Torre de la Justicia original entry gate to the Alhambra and the walk way to the June evening s Concurso events 比賽的場地 编辑 比賽在阿爾罕布拉宮西面的 54 的Plaza de Aljibes 舉行 跟 Torre Bermeja 還有西南邊的格拉那達老城區對望 北邊是吉普賽區Sacromonte的山坡 55 充滿了柏木的香味 地面上還灑了法國薰衣草 廣場在山脊頂 要穿過正義之塔旁邊的路才能到達 廣場由Ignacio Zuloaga的作品布置 上面還掛著鑲邊的紡織品跟披肩 在太陽西下時 整個場地就變成了這個阿拉伯宮殿旁邊一塊充滿色彩的區塊 56 57 評審團包括了吉他手Andres Segovia跟佛朗明哥歌手Antonio Chacon 可能有點諷刺的一點是 開場表演是由 Segovia 演奏法雅的古典音樂作品 用吉他對德布西致敬 58 59 60 參賽者 编辑 一個退休很久的72歲佛朗明哥歌手Diego Bermudez Cala 藝名El Tenazas 意外成為比賽的超級明星 他從家鄉 Puente Genil 花了三天走了大概一百公里到格拉那達去參加比賽 61 很明顯的 三十年前被刀尖刺穿肺部 導致他從佛朗明哥圈子提早退休了 這項比賽讓他重享他生命中的重要時刻 他演唱的曲式是屬於上一個時代的 很多人覺得 Bermudez 的歌唱聽起來 似乎就是得到傳奇歌手Silverio Franconetti的真傳 雖然一些其他人說他不知道怎麼唱歌 只會調情 62 63 El Tenazas 知道古老的曲調 並且用非常佛朗明哥風味的方式去詮釋它們 他用一種幾十年來沒人聽過的純粹佛朗明哥方式歌唱 尤其是在 siguiriyas 孤調 and canas Silverio Franconetti 最喜歡的曲式之一 64 在聽到El Tenazas 意思是 鉗子 歌唱時 把他的歌聲拋到天上 Antonio Chacon驚呼了 老天爺 我聽到了甚麼 65 法雅後來 1939 年因為佛朗哥將軍打贏了西班牙內戰 而流亡到阿根廷的時候 還帶了一份 El Tenazas 的錄音 Cantos de Diego Bermudez 去 66 El Tenazas 很享受他突然回復的名氣 藉此他接下來就在西班牙各地巡迴演出佛朗明哥歌唱 但很可惜的 一年後他就去世了 67 另外一個首獎得主是年僅十二歲的 Manolo Ortega 後來被稱為El Caracol 出身於一個知名的鬥牛士跟吉普賽家庭 後來獲得的極大的名聲 也引起了很大的爭議 68 69 另一個贏家是出身格拉那達的流行歌手Francisco Galvez Gomez Yerbaguena 他以當地一個教堂火災為題材 即興寫了佛朗明哥歌詞來表演 讓觀眾留下深刻印象 70 總共有十個參賽者贏得了數目不等的獎金 71 72 專家表演 编辑 專業佛朗明哥藝術家在比賽中雖然不能參加有獎金的比賽 依然還是被尊崇的 並且列為特別來賓 包括了女歌手Pastora Pavon La Nina de los Peines 73 男歌手Manuel Torre 女舞者Juana la Macarrona 還有男歌手Antonio Chacon 被選為評審 這四位當時已經很有名了 在一幅繪畫中畫出了藝術家們在比賽舉辦人面前表演 La Nina de los Peines 前面提過的退休的El Tenazas 還有創新的佛朗明哥吉他手 Ramon Montoya Salazar 74 另外也有一位在巴黎開佛朗明哥咖啡館的 Amalio Cuenca 也被選為評審 75 專業藝術家從從西班牙各地甚至外國來參加比賽 在比賽中 偉大的 Manuel Torre 配著當地 Sacromonte 區的吉普賽女人的擊掌 吟唱了歡愉調 alegrias Maria Amaya La Gazpacha 唱了喧戲調 bulerias 跟tarantas 由Pepe Cuellar 彈吉他幫她伴奏 76 Ramon Montoya Manolo de Huelva 跟 Jose Cuellar 這三位被比賽聘請的吉他手 組成了吉他三重奏 為年長的舞蹈大師Juana la Macarrona 页面存档备份 存于互联网档案馆 表演的 alegrias 舞蹈伴奏 77 78 La Macarrona 她在比賽途中有時候會大聲喊叫 Lapoteosis Es lapoteosis 意思類似於 打雷了 79 在比賽中一場表演 Antonio Chacon 唱歌 Ramon Montoya 伴奏 一個衣衫藍縷的吉普賽女人安靜的哭泣 站起來抬起頭 配著音樂跳了一首極為動人且優雅的孤調 她其實是幾十年前一個有名的佛朗明哥舞者 La Golondrina 80 比賽的新聞 编辑 跟摩洛哥戰爭令人沮喪的消息相比 西班牙媒體普遍讚揚這次比賽 81 一家馬德里雜誌新世界描述這次比賽是 令人難忘的 關於觀眾 它這樣描寫 月亮沒有參加 但是比賽場地擠滿了小精靈 仙子 甚至魔鬼 一個超級票房冠軍 座無虛席 並且是一群有紀律 有文化的觀眾 觀眾主要是女性 穿著 1830 年的服裝 其他人穿著老式的長褲 她們所有人帶著格拉那達人特有的穩重 群眾扇著扇子交談著 直到一首歌曲用感動麻痺了群眾們 82 格拉那達的雜誌阿爾罕布拉宮盛讚比賽為 精彩的晚會 在馬德里 媒體評論宣稱 比賽非常的成功 83 雖然如此 法雅還是失望的 84 後續發展 编辑 nbsp Manuel de Falla 1876 1946 比賽的表演廣受好評 但比賽的成果則有爭議 85 比賽本身很令人享受 也成功的集結了表演者跟樂迷 並且提升了佛朗明哥在西班牙的文化界領袖心中的地位 86 各種佛朗明哥曲式的錄音被灌錄了 有些曲式之前很少人知道 有些曲式則是被重新發現 87 比如 La Cana 它是一種古老的曲式 用宗教旋律跟吟唱橋段 讓它成為 佛朗明哥彌撒 在二十世紀幾乎完全消失了 卻在 1922 年格拉那達的比賽中 由優勝者 El Tenazas 的錄音被重新發現了 88 另一方面 提升佛朗明哥表演純淨本質的目的 卻沒有達成 89 佛朗明哥劇場時代即將來臨 這是一種在現代已經因為它擺架子的形式 跟其他音樂的混合 被鄙視的形式 90 91 在同一年 類似的佛朗明哥比賽也在賽維亞跟加地斯舉行了 92 93 幾十年後的 1956 年哥多華市舉行了全國深沈之歌比賽 94 在 1962 年Jerez de la Frontera舉辦了國際佛朗明哥藝術比賽 這樣的活動已經成為佛朗明哥文化的一種常態 95 外部連結 编辑http www flamenco world com magazine about historia del flamenco paginas 25 htm 页面存档备份 存于互联网档案馆 比賽冠軍有 8500 pesetas 的獎金 參考來源 编辑 Eduardo Molina Fajardo Manuel de Falla y El Cante Jondo Universidad de Granada 1962 2d edition 1998 with new preface at ix cviii by Andres Soria at lxi lxx and 54 57 Angel Alvarez Caballero El cante flamenco Madrid Alianza Editorial 1994 at 212 Felix Grande Memoria del Flamenco Madrid Espasa Calpe 1979 at II 481 Manuel Orozco Diaz Falla Barcelona Salvat 1985 at 123 124 Barbara Thiel Cramer Flamenco The Art of Flamenco Its History and Development until our Days Lindingo Sweden Remark 1990 Swedish 1991 Spanish German English at 51 52 法雅也打算邀請音樂家 拉威爾 跟俄國的史特拉汶斯基 但是市政府拒絕提供提供旅費 2012 01 21 Eduardo Molina Fajardo Manuel de Falla y El Cante Jondo Universidad de Granada 1962 2d edition 1998 at 13 23 17 Thesoleares in Falla s La Vida Breve is mentioned during a review of Falla s classical compositions relating to flamenco music Molina Fajardo at 15 gives his opinion as to how in general Falla incorporated flamenco elements in his art by drinking in and assimilating their spirit and then expressing their musical essence Later he comments on the pervasive use of flamenco in Noches en los Jardines de Espana El Amor Brujo and El Sombrero de Tres Picos In Falla s Noches Gypsies dance and sing during the feast of Corpus Christi the days later selected by Falla for the Concurso Betty Keim Manuel de Falla the Guitar and his Music in The Guitar Review Winter 1976 41 22 23 wherein Keim mentions the melodies inspired bycante jondo and the rasgueado and punteado in his Noches en los Jardines de Espana which ends with a sevillana Cf Lynn Garafola Diaghilev s Ballets Russes Oxford Univ 1989 at 88 90 discussing Falla and flamenco dance projects circa 1916 1917 Falla s El Sombrero de Tres Picos The Three cornered Hat Fr Le Tricorne choreographed by Leonide Massine designs by Pablo Picasso was produced by the Ballets Russes in 1919 Garafola 1989 at 88 243 253 The flamenco and Spanish origin of both the music and the dance in Le Tricorne is described by Leonide Massine in his My Life in Ballet London Macmillan 1968 at 114 118 122 Betty Keim Manuel de Falla the Guitar and his Music in The Guitar Review Winter 1976 41 22 23 Keim mentions several other examples of Falla s use of flamenco the modified farruca for the Miller s Dance Danza del Molinero in his El Sombrero de Tres Picos at the end the miller becomes possessed by the duende and the falsetas and paseos in his Siete Canciones Populares Espanoles 1914 where she again remarks that his piano pieces seem written as if they were guitar music especially regarding the Polo as well as the Seguidilla Murciana Keim also references the memorable Ritual Fire Dance in his El Amor Brujo which is performed at night in a Gypsi camp Manuel de Falla El cante jondo canto primitivo andaluz a folleto Granada Urania 1922 included in Molina Fajardo Manuel de Falla y El Cante Jondo 1962 1998 at 209 226 Byzantine liturgical at 209 210 Arabic Moorish at 210 211 225 226 Gypsies of India at 211 216 and collected in Falla s Escritos sobre musica y musicos Madrid Espasa Calpe 1950 1972 Apendice at 137 155 Falla here refers to his former music professor Felipe Pedrell 1841 1922 Cf Peter Crossley Holland Ancient Greece at 92 103 and Alec Robertson Byzantine and Russian Rites at 201 208 in Robertson and Stevens eds The Pelican History of Music Penguin Books 1960 Cf Adolfo Salazar La Musica de Espana Madrid Espasa Calpe 1953 vol I at Chap III 1 137 149 Also the religious music of the Jews who had arrived in Hispania by 300 C E Salazar La Musica de Espana 1953 v I at I 5 42 46 Cf Julian Ribera y Tarego La Musica de las Cantigas Madrid 1922 translated and abridged by Eleanor Hague and Marion Leffingwell as Music in Ancient Arabia and Spain Stanford Univ 1929 Arcadio de Larrea Palacin La Musica Hispano Arabe Madrid Ateneo 1957 a folleto Cf Owen Wright Music in Muslim Spain 555 579 in Salma Khadra Jayyusi editor The Legacy of Muslim Spain Leiden E J Brill 1992 Aziz Balouchi Cante Jondo Su origen y evolucion Madrid Editiones Ensayos 1955 at 30 38 The author a sufi discusses the spirit of Indo Pakistani music then describes six principal modes A tree is shown at 37 whose fruit is cante jondo i e serranas soleares polos seguirillas canas Earlier the author speculates that Ziryab the famous Persian musician who arrived in Moorish Spain during the 9th century was a master of la musica persa baluchi had studied el cantar Sindhi in India and brought with him to Spain la musica indostanica Balouchi 1955 at 24 28 26 Bernard Leblon Gypsies and Flamenco Univ of Hertfordshire 1995 Leblon who favored the view of a strong Gitano influence on the art addresses the theories proposed by Falla at 85 91 Leblon discounts Falla regarding the Byzantines then endorses influence by the Moors Regarding India and Gitano contributions to flamenco Leblon writes that here Falla makes five points 1 use of intervals less than a demi tone smallest interval common to western music to modulate keys 2 a melodic ambitus which rarely exceeds the limits of a sixth ninehalf notes 3 repeated almost obsessive use of a single note often with appoggiatura 4 melody rich in ornamentation suiting the emotion of the lyrics 5 shouts jaleos used by our people to excite the dancers and guitarists following ancient custom Leblon 1995 at 88 Angus Fraser The Gypsies Oxford Blackwell 1992 2d ed 1995 at 10 32 origin at 205 208 flamenco The Gypsi road from India to Spain with music along the way is displayed in the 1993 French film Latcho Drom Manuel de Falla El cante jondo canto primitivo andaluz a folleto Granada Urania 1922 included in Molina Fajardo Manuel de Falla y El Cante Jondo 1962 1998 at 209 226 217 225 collected in Falla s Escritos sobre musica y musicos Madrid Espasa Calpe 1950 1972 Apendice 137 155 Falla noted that the foreign borrowing of Spanish music went beyond rhythm usual with dances of other European countries e g the jig the saraband the gavote the minuet it went further to the basic modes of expression found in Spanish music Falla 1922 reprinted in Molina Fajardo 1998 at 218 Gilbert Chase The Music of Spain New York W W Norton 1941 rev ed New York Dover 1959 at 289 304 The Spell of Spanish Music Gilbert discusses Falla at 182 197 The list would include these composers and works Mikhail Glinka Jota Aragonesa 1845 Georges Bizet Carmen 1875 Nikolai Rimsky Korsakov Capriccio Espagnol 1887 Claude Debussy Iberia 1905 1908 Maurice Ravel Rapsodie espagnole 1907 and Bolero 1928 Pues bien senores ese tesoro de belleza no solo amenaza ruina sino que esta apunto de desaparecer para siempre El canto grave hieratico de ayer ha degenerado en el ridiculo flamenquismo de hoy Manuel de Falla La proposicion del cante jondo en El Defensor de Granada March 21 1922 reprinted in Molina Fajardo Manuel de Falla y El Cante Jondo 1962 1998 at 169 175 173 Well gentlemen this beautiful treasure not only is about to collapse but may disappear forever The song of gravitas majestic yesterday has sunk now to this absurd flamenquismo Carol A Hess Manuel de Falla and modernism in Spain 1898 1936 University of Chicago 2001 at 175 footnote omitted An entry ticket to the event reads Concurso y Fiesta del Cante Jondo Corpus 1922 Entrada de Silla Preferente para los dias 13 y 14 de Junio Entrada por la Puerta de Justicia Presentese a toda reclamacion Molina Fajardo 1998 insert at 129 Would renacieron en toda su pureza esos cantos de maravilla que constituyen uno de los mas legitimos orgullos de musica natural europea Manuel de Falla La proposicion del cante jondo Granada 1922 reprinted in Molina Fajardo 1962 1998 at 169 175 174 175 Timothy Mitchell in his Flamenco Deep Song New Haven Yale University 1994 disputes the very notion of a traditional purity as advanced by Concurso proponents For example regarding the seguiriya gitana Mitchell describes it as a result of lower class gitanos payo non Gitano ruffians blind beggars female mourners for hire and proletarian youth which later was evolved in the 19th century by professional cantaores entertaining within the cultural maze of Spanish society at venues including private juergas parties and public saloons Mitchell 1994 at 168 Written application for support was made on December 31 1921 giving artistic and cultural reasons as redacted by Miguel Ceron and signed by several dozen adherents Molina Fajardo Manuel de Falla y El Cante Jondo 1962 1998 at 51 58 51 53 also Solicitud Al Ayuntamiento de Granada reprinted in Molina Fajardo 1998 as Apendice II at 163 167 Alvarez Caballero El cante flamenco 1994 at 217 gives the amount of city funding at 30 000pesetas Eduardo Molina Fajardo Manuel de Falla y El Cante Jondo Universidad de Granada 1962 2d ed 1998 at 69 87 Timothy Mitchell Flamenco Deep Song New Haven Yale University 1994 at 168 169 Robin Totton Song of the Outcasts Portland Oregon Amadeus Press 2003 at 84 Leblon Gypsies and Flamenco University of Hertfordshire 1995 at 87 88 We want to purify and renew the admirablecante jondo which is not to be confused with flamenco a degeneration of it almost a caricature 法雅寫給倫敦評論家 John Trend 的信 Molina Fajardo 引用在 Manuel de Falla y El Cante Jondo 書中 1962 1998 76 77 頁 Cf Angel Alvarez Caballero El cante flamenco Madrid Alianza Editorial 1994 at 213 214 Eduardo Molina Fajardo in his Manuel de Falla y El Cante Jondo Universidad de Granada 1962 2d ed 1998 at 92 93 141 Among factors in the cauldron are the dynamic opposition of flamenco tradition versus innovation the latter frequently including interpenetration with other musical styles E g Manuel Rios Ruiz Ayer y Hoy del cante flameno Madrid Ediciones ISTMO 1997 at 85 95 Recent decades have seen Nuevo Flamenco emerge with rock and jazz connections Flamenco motivation is notoriously difficult to pin down Existe en plenitud anarquica independiente de todo acicate organizado Fully anarchic blind to organized incentives Anselmo Gazalez Climent Flamencologia Toros Cante y Baile Madrid Editorial Escelicer 1955 1964 at 272 See Gazalez Climent s comments on the nuance involved in the role of La guasa the tricky humorous rustic at 329 341 On occasion political passions may be stirred in a sociological view of the art as embodying the anguished expression of the poor the oppressed classes Yet to the contrary others see flamenco performers of the past who were often short of resources as influenced by their wealthy patrons who had a taste for the exotic An ethnic dimension also arises as to how much the art owes to its strong Gitano elements or to the Andalusian Altogether contrary is the opinion that in flamenco what one hears is the cry of the soul transcending class patrons ethnicity etc Wide ranging views are held by flamencologos on the art and on what motivates a performer E g Anselmo Gazalez Climent Flamencologia Toros Cante y Baile Madrid Editorial Escelicer 1955 1964 William Washabaugh Flamenco Passion politics and popular culture Oxford Berg 1996 at 31 38 Molina Fajardo in Manuel de Falla y El Cante Jondo 1962 2d ed 1998 at 129 131 Andres Soria Prefacio at lxix in Eduardo Molina Fajardo Manuel de Falla y El Cante Jondo Universidad de Granada 1962 2d edition 1998 with new preface at ix cviii by Soria The performance of flamenco is very difficult and demanding only someone who devotes a great deal of their life s nurture to the art will be able to express its subtleties and nuance its drama and simplicity often but not always such refinement will acquire wide attention Cf Paco Sevilla Introductory History of Flamenco Part II in Jaleo VIII 2 originally published in Guitar and Lute March 1983 at 14 The elimination of all professionals from the contest was considered a mistake by many flamencos for there were those who had not fallen to the era s commercial tendencies An example would be the professionals hired by the Concurso the cantaora Pastora Pavon La Nina de los Peines the cantaor Manuel Torre and the bailaora Juana la Macarrona These had unlike many paid performers of that decadent era maintained a purity in their approach to flamenco Cf D E Pohren Lives and Legends of Flamenco Madrid 1964 revised 1988 at 73 Paul Hecht in his The Wind Cried New York The Dial Press 1968 at 105 107 describes a dream vision of a flamenco contest in which the performers and local aficionados are given preference Lasting at minimum several weeks it would begin with a banquet and include hotel accommodations Before each session time would be allowed for thawing out the voice and interacting with the listeners At extra official Juergas flamenco s pure spontaneous essence would be given rein Timothy Mitchell Flameno Deep Song Yale Univ 1994 at 170 The liviana derived from liviano meaning light frivolous and also the donkey who leads the pack is a type of siguiriya sung without accompaniment Andres Batista Maestros y Estilos Manual flamenco Madrid 1985 at 18 19 74 75 Marice Legendre El Corpus de Granada in 1922 El Cante Jondo in the periodical Le Correspondant of Paris July 1922 cited by Molina Fajardo 1998 at 131 132 A storm threatened the first night but the air remained light The second night rain began to fall yet the audience remained Molina Fajardo Manuel de Falla y El Cante Jondo 1998 at 132 140 Believed for the most part to be of Gitano Gypsi origin I e by D E Pohren Lives and Legends of Flamenco A Biographical History Madrid Society of Spanish Studies 1964 1988 at 17 20 The brief Concurso prize and contest rules are reprinted in Manuel de Falla Escritos sobre musica y musicos Madrid Espasa Calpe 1950 1972 at 156 162 in the Apendice following his essay El Cante Jondo Canto Primitivo Andaluz at 137 155 translated as On Music and Musicians London Marion Boyars 1979 at end of Appendix 99 117 The Alhambra had been the site of the opening for Falla s opera El Sombrero de Tres Picos French Le Tricorne three years ealier in 1919 Leonide Massine My Life in Ballet London Macmillan 1968 at 142 Ricardo Villa Real The Alhambra and the Generalife Granada Ed Miguel Sanchez 1988 at 6 7 Molina Fajardo Manuel de Falla y El Cante Jondo Univ de Granada 1962 2d ed 1998 at 118 119 Irving Brown Deep Song New York Harper amp Brothers 1929 at 149 150 Molina Fajardo Manuel de Falla y El Cante Jondo Univ de Granada 1962 2d ed 1998 at 116 It was Claude Debussy who had first shown Falla how to find the flamenco s true spirit in the guitar music of the cante jondo Ibid at 17 18 Nota Bene Segovia at this time played flamenco as well as classical guitar to the latter he would soon devote his entire effort Pohlen Lives and Legends of Flamenco Madrid 1964 revised 1988 at 73 Cf Betty Keim in her Manuel de Falla the Guitar and his Music published in The Guitar Review Winter 1976 41 22 23 notes that Falla called meeting Claude Debussy the turning point of his career Falla wrote the Homenaje following Debussy s death in 1918 then gave it to the guitarist Miguel Llobet The score is widely acclaimed for its mastery of the instrument and while not flamenco its beauty resonates with the music of Andalusia Puente Genil is about 50 km south of Cordoba Diego Bermudez was born 1850 at Moron de la Frontera about 70 km southwest of Puente Genil Pohlen Lives and Legends of Flamenco 1988 at 71 Angel Alvarez Caballero El cante flamenco Madrid Alianza Editorial 1994 at 218 219 Burmudez habia dejado de cantar treinta anos antes al perder facultades a causa de una punalada recibada en el pulmon durante una reyerta His punctured lung Ibid at 218 Fixed to a wall of a cafe in Puente Genil could later be seen a certificate signed by Antonio Chacon that the Concurso had awarded to Tio Bermudez at 219 The walk from Puente Genil to Granada for the Concurso was said to have taken him only three days but long and exhausting ones but some doubt he walked the distance at 218 Cf Molina Fajardo Manuel de Falla y El Cante Jondo Univ de Granada 1962 2d ed 1998 at 135 136 140 D E Pohlen Lives and Legends of Flamenco 1988 at 71 72 Lord help me what I hear Jose Luis Cano Garcia Lorca Barcelona Salvat Editores 1985 at 55 Felix Grande Memoria del Flamenco Madrid Espasa Calpe 1979 at II 507 Before he died el Tio Tenazas traveled Spain performing his prize winning singing style but as his innovations had already been copied by younger singers the tour was evidently not well received Timothy Mitchell Flamenco Deep Song Yale Univ 1994 at 171 Eduardo Molina Fajardo Manuel de Falla y El Cante Jondo Universidade Granada 1962 2d ed 1998 at 133 141 D E Pohren Lives and Legends of Flamenco Madrid Society of Spanish Studies 1985 at 146 150 148 Angel Alvarez Caballero El cante flamenco Madrid Alianza Editorial 1994 at 219 220 Yerbaguena figured in the novel La oracion de la tarde by Gonzalez Anaya The poet Alvarez de Cienfuegos recited at his burial Eduardo Molina Fajardo lists the prize winners in his Manuel de Falla y El Cante Jondo Univ de Granada 1962 2d ed 1998 at 141 142 The top two prize winners received 1000 pesetas each with total prize money for the contestants being almost 5000 Yet he cites a newspaper of Seville to the effect that the biggest winners was the Concurso organizer Centro Artistico who after event expenses with the gate 6 000 pesetas added to public funding managed to come out ahead Molina Fajardo 1998 at 142 Alvarez Caballero El cante flamenco 1994 at 217 puts the gate at 30 000 and at 213 puts the public funding at 12 000 Expense amounts do not seem to be stated Pastora Pavon was also an honorary judge but without a vote Paco Sevilla Queen of the Gypsies 1999 at 153 Angel Alvarez Caballero El cante flamenco Madrid Alianza Editorial 1994 at 216 210 drawing D E Pohlen Lives and Legends of Flamenco Madrid 1964 revised 1988 at 273 Cuenca Also Pohlen s literary portraits at 112 114 Pavon at 91 97 Torre at 212 215 Macarrona and at 76 80 Chacon Eduardo Molina Fajardo Manuel de Falla y El Cante Jondo Universidad de Granada 1962 2d ed 1998 at 136 139 Maria Amaya was also a prize winner Ibid at 142 Pohlen Lives and Legends of Flamenco 1964 1988 at 73 Antonia Merce la Argentina after watching Juana la Macarrona dance during the Concurso later knelt down at her feet took off her shoes and carried them away Flamenco World article on Juana la Macarrona 页面存档备份 存于互联网档案馆 Molina Fajardo Manuel de Falla y el Cante Jondo 1962 2d ed 1988 at 136 139 Timothy Mitchell Flamenco Deep Song Yale Univ 1994 at 170 Some Concurso critics however seemed to revisit the earlier contra position see above the section Public funding Frederico Garcia Sanchiz Granada El Concurso de Cante Jondo 页面存档备份 存于互联网档案馆 馬德里的雜誌 Nuevo Mundo 新世界 1922年6月23 flamenco world com 網站的英文翻譯 A few nights of brilliance Great has been the success of the Concurso Eduardo Molina Fajardo Manuel de Falla y El Cante Jondo Universidad de Granada 1962 2d ed 1998 at 144 Eduardo Molina Fajardo Manuel de Falla y El Cante Jondo 1962 1998 at 151 157 The sevillano Rodriguez de Leon writing in El Sol lamented the Concurso as cause of the funerales por el alma del cante muerto recientemente en Granada a manos de los intelectuales Cited by Angel Alvarez Caballero El cante flamenco Madrid Alianza Editorial 1994 at 217 I e the lamented Concurso has caused funerals for the soul of the cante recently dead in Granada at the hands of the intellectuals Felix Grande Memoria del Flamenco Madrid Espasa Calpe 1979 at II 514 Paco Sevilla Introductory History of Flamenco Part II inJaleo VIII 2 originally published in Guitar and Lute March 1983 at 14 Paco Sevilla Queen of the Gypsies The Life and Legend of Carmen Amaya San Diego 1999 at 197 The initial elation and sense of accomplishment by those attending the event was manifest Yet following the Concurso in addition to the usual sniping at success in the press there was a distressing sense of loss felt by the Concurso organizers Hence they abandoned pursuit of their original long term goals plans scheduled to be implimented following the Concurso event It was disillusioning to the organizers that the true purpose of the concurso failed at least during their lifetimes The Granada contest was designed as only the first step As a followup they intended to open flamenco schools in Andalusian cities and to hire flamenco s old timers to instruct the youngsters in the pure cante The Centro Artistico of Granada which was to have played an important part in this plan at the last minute pulled out and the whole idea collapsed D E Pohren Lives and Legends of Flamenco Madrid Society of Spanish Studies 1964 revised 1988 at 73 74 Yet the continuance of Concurso events in different cities and the current spread offlamenco schools perhaps means that Manuel de Falla s dream may yet come true D E Pohren 1964 1988 at 74 Or perhaps now his dream has been realized in part Felix Grande Memoria del Flamenco Madrid Espasa Calpe 1979 at II 517 539 Angel Alvarez Caballero El cante flamenco Madrid Alianza Editorial 1994 at 229 244 Felix Grande Memoria del Flamenco Madrid Espasa Calpe 1979 at II 513 Cf Paco Sevilla Queen of the Gypsies 1999 at 40 41 Angel Alvarez Caballero El cante flamenco Madrid Alianza Editorial 1994 1998 at 262 Felix Grande Memoria del Flamenco Madrid Espasa Calpe 1979 at II 513 514 取自 https zh wikipedia org w index php title 深沈之歌比賽 amp oldid 74166621, 维基百科，wiki，书籍，书籍，图书馆，

文章

，阅读，下载，免费，免费下载，mp3，视频，mp4，3gp， jpg，jpeg，gif，png，图片，音乐，歌曲，电影，书籍，游戏，游戏。